Rent vs Buy Calculator

Renting pays rent and keeps the flexibility; buying pays a mortgage, tax, insurance and maintenance and ends with an asset you can sell. This calculator adds up both paths year by year, nets the buying side against the sale value after selling costs and the mortgage balance, and shows the first year owning pulls ahead.

Your numbers

Dollar amounts and percentages only. Every calculation runs in your browser.

Enter a value to see results

Cost year by year

Rent is added up as it is paid. The buying column adds the down payment, closing costs, mortgage payments, property tax, insurance and maintenance, plus the return the down payment would have earned, then subtracts what the house would net after selling costs and the remaining loan balance. The last column shows that sale figure on its own.

Cumulative cost by year, net of the sale proceeds at the end of that year
Year Cumulative rent cost Cumulative net cost of buying Net sale value
Enter a value to see results

What the numbers say at 5, 7 and 10 years

How this is calculated

Two running totals are built year by year and compared at the end of the horizon you choose. The buying side starts with three one-time amounts: the down payment, closing costs on the purchase, and the difference between the down payment and what it would have grown to if invested at your return rate.

down = home price * down percent / 100 P = home price - down monthly PI = P * r * (1 + r)^n / ((1 + r)^n - 1) when r > 0, else P / n rent cash flow(y) = rent * 12 * (1 + rent growth / 100)^(y-1) home value(y) = home price * (1 + appreciation / 100)^y buy cash flow(y) = monthly PI * 12 + home value(y) * tax rate / 100 + insurance * 1.03^(y-1) + home value(y) * maintenance / 100 balance(y) = loan balance after month 12y net sale value(y) = home value(y) * (1 - selling costs / 100) - balance(y) down opportunity(y) = down * (1 + investment return / 100)^y cumulative rent(y) = sum of rent cash flow, years 1..y cumulative buy(y) = down + home price * buying costs / 100 + sum of buy cash flow, years 1..y + (down opportunity(y) - down) - net sale value(y)

Each year then adds twelve mortgage payments, property tax on that year's home value, an insurance premium that rises 3 percent a year, and maintenance at your percentage of the home value. Principal and interest stops once the loan is repaid, so a horizon longer than the term continues with taxes, insurance and maintenance only.

The selling side reduces the buying total: at the end of each year the home is valued at your appreciation rate, selling costs are deducted, and the mortgage balance after that year's payments is subtracted, which leaves the cash you would walk away with. The renting side is simpler: rent for the year, grown at your rent growth rate, added to the running total. Rent for year one is twelve months at today's rent; year two is that figure grown once, and so on.

The difference between the two totals is the answer, and the break-even year is the first year in which the buying total falls to or below the renting total.

Assumptions

Frequently asked questions

What does this calculator compare?

It compares two cash flows for the same household over the same number of years. Renting pays rent every month and builds no asset. Buying pays a mortgage, property tax, insurance and maintenance, and ends with a house that can be sold. Both sides are added up year by year, and the buying side is reduced by the net sale value, so the two totals can be compared directly.

Why is the down payment counted only once?

The down payment is real money that leaves your account at closing, so it is counted once, in the buying total. It is not repeated inside the yearly cash flow, because the monthly mortgage payment covers only the loan. The buying total also adds the return the down payment would have earned if it stayed invested, minus the down payment itself, so the two sides are compared on the same footing.

How is the break-even year found?

The break-even year is the first year in which the cumulative net cost of buying is less than or equal to the cumulative cost of renting. Before that point renting has cost less; after it, owning has. Because selling costs, closing costs and the mortgage balance all move, the crossing can be sharp or it can never happen within your horizon, in which case the page says buying does not break even in that window.

What is left out of the comparison?

The model has no PMI and no HOA dues, and it does not deduct mortgage interest or property tax on a tax return. Renters insurance, security deposits, moving costs, utilities that differ between a rental and a house, special assessments, and any renovation you would not otherwise do are also outside the model. Each of those can move the answer by thousands of dollars, so use the result as a starting point rather than a verdict.

Which appreciation and rent growth numbers should I use?

There is no default that fits every market, so the fields start at 3 percent for both and you are expected to change them. A useful habit is to run three scenarios: your base case, a flat market with zero appreciation and zero rent growth, and a stress case where home values fall while rent keeps rising. The break-even year usually moves a lot between them, and that range is more informative than a single number.

Still deciding on the loan itself? Read fixed versus adjustable rates or how mortgage payments are calculated.

Estimates only, not financial advice. Results depend on the assumptions you enter, and this model does not forecast home prices or rents. See Disclaimer.