Fixed vs Adjustable Rate Mortgages

A fixed-rate mortgage holds one interest rate for the whole term, so the principal and interest payment never changes. An adjustable-rate mortgage starts lower, then resets to an index plus a margin, limited by caps. The fixed loan pays more now for certainty; the adjustable loan pays less now and carries the rate risk from the first reset onward.

Who carries the rate risk

The two loans differ in one place: who absorbs a change in interest rates. With a fixed rate, the lender does. Your payment is set on day one and stays there for 360 months, whatever happens to market yields, inflation or the index that other loans track. The price of that certainty is embedded in the rate, and it is why a fixed rate is normally above the starter rate of an adjustable loan offered at the same moment.

With an adjustable rate, you carry it. The loan is cheaper while the initial rate lasts and reprices afterwards on a schedule written into the note. Nothing about your credit, income or payment history changes the new rate; the CFPB is direct that once the initial period ends, adjustments follow the market rather than your personal finances (CFPB, retrieved 2026, consumerfinance.gov).

Both loans amortize identically while the rate holds, so the mortgage payment calculator gives an accurate bill for either one up to the first reset. After that, only the fixed loan's number stays true. The gap between the two starter rates is not a discount either: it is what the market charges to hand the risk to you, and the caps in the note define how much of that risk you can be made to pay for.

How a reset works: index, margin and caps

A reset is arithmetic, not negotiation. The new rate is an index plus a margin. The index is a published rate that moves with the market; the margin is a fixed number of percentage points written into your note at closing and it does not change afterwards. Add them and you have the fully indexed rate, which is the rate you would pay if no cap interfered.

Three caps then limit the result. The initial adjustment cap limits the first change after the fixed period; the subsequent, or periodic, cap limits each change after that; the lifetime cap limits the total move from the starting rate. CFPB guidance describes the common shapes: an initial cap of two or five points, periodic caps of one or two points, and a lifetime cap of five points, with some loans carrying higher limits and a separate floor for decreases (CFPB, retrieved 2026, consumerfinance.gov).

The new payment is then recalculated on the remaining balance over the remaining term, so the balance at the reset date is what the new rate multiplies. The amortization schedule calculator gives that balance for any start date you are weighing.

Five years and ten years, side by side

Comparing a fixed and an adjustable loan on the monthly payment alone hides the point of the adjustable loan, which is the cost over the years you actually hold it. The table prices the same $400,000 loan both ways at this site's calculator: fixed at 6.5% for 30 years, or adjustable at 5.5% whose first five years are fixed.

Five-year and ten-year cost of a $400,000 loan at 6.5% fixed versus 5.5% for the first five years, per this site's mortgage payment calculator; the adjustable column holds 5.5% except in the last row, which prices a reset to 7.5%
Measure Fixed 6.5%, 30 years Adjustable, 5.5% start
Monthly principal and interest $2,528.27 $2,271.16
Paid over the first 60 payments $151,696.20 $136,269.60
Balance after 60 payments $374,443.91 $369,842.41
Paid over the first 120 payments (no reset) $303,392.40 $272,539.20
Balance after 120 payments (no reset) $339,104.51 $330,163.96
Payment after a reset to 7.5% at month 61 $2,528.27 $2,733.10

Over five years the adjustable loan pays $15,426.60 less and still owes $4,601.50 less, about $20,028 of interest avoided once the schedule is summed row by row. The last row shows what buys it back: at 7.5% the payment becomes $2,733.10, $204.83 above the fixed payment, so the $15,426.60 of payments saved in the first five years is given back over roughly 75 further payments on cash paid alone, before the lower balance is netted in. Ten years of the same comparison widen the gap: the adjustable loan has paid $30,853.20 less and owes about $8,941 less, roughly $39,794 of interest avoided, still assuming the rate never moved. The refinance break-even calculator answers the follow-on question if a reset arrives while fixed rates are lower than the new note rate.

Which loan fits which holding period

The variable that decides this is how long you keep the loan, not how long you keep the house in the abstract. If you sell or refinance before the first reset, the adjustable loan's lower rate is collected in full and the reset never happens. If you are still paying after the reset, the arithmetic reverses and the rate you did not choose becomes the rate you have.

That makes three questions worth answering before comparing quotes. How many years until the first reset, and is it longer than your realistic holding period? What is the lifetime cap, and can you make the payment at that ceiling for a year without touching savings reserved for anything else? Which index does the note reference, and how far has it moved in the last tightening cycle? A payment at the lifetime cap is the stress test; anything less is a scenario.

A useful rule of thumb: a planned refinance has to survive both a higher rate and a lower appraisal, so the decision should rest on the payment you can carry at the cap rather than the payment you would like to have. If the decision is entangled with whether to own at all, the rent vs buy calculator prices the owning path with tax, insurance, maintenance and appreciation, which is the context a rate comparison sits inside.

Why our calculators hold the rate fixed

Every calculator on this site treats the interest rate as fixed for the full term, and that is a deliberate limit rather than an oversight. Forecasting an index would mean inventing a path for rates, and a fabricated path produces a precise-looking number that nobody should rely on. Holding the rate fixed gives an exact answer to a narrower question: what does this loan cost at this rate, and how does that change with amount, rate and term?

For an adjustable loan the honest use is two runs. Price the loan at its starter rate for the initial period to see the payment you will actually make until the first reset, then price the remaining balance at the fully indexed rate and at the lifetime cap to see the range afterwards. That bracket is more useful than a single blended number, because the note does not promise a blend.

The down payment calculator covers the other half of the trade: a larger down payment can change the rate you are offered and removes mortgage insurance, while the reset mechanics stay exactly the same. The methodology page lists the formula and defaults behind every figure.

Frequently asked questions

What does the 5/1 in a 5/1 ARM mean?

The first number is how many years the initial rate is fixed, and the second is how often the rate can adjust after that, measured in years. A 5/1 loan holds its starting rate for five years and can then change once a year, subject to its caps. A 5/6 loan holds for five years and adjusts every six months. The label describes the schedule only; it says nothing about the margin, the index or the caps, which are in the note and on the disclosures.

Do the caps apply to decreases as well as increases?

They usually apply in both directions, with the same numeric limits, although some loans carry a separate floor that limits how far the rate can fall. The lifetime cap is measured from the initial rate, so a five-point cap on a 5.5% start means the rate cannot exceed 10.5% or fall more than five points below 5.5%. Read the note for whether the floor differs from the cap, because that asymmetry is where caps quietly stop protecting you.

Why is the fixed payment higher than the adjustable one at the start?

Because the lender is charging for certainty. On a fixed loan the lender carries the risk that rates rise over 30 years, and the rate includes the cost of that risk. An adjustable loan transfers that risk to you after the initial period, so the starting rate is lower. The gap is not free money; it is the price of the risk you have agreed to take, and the caps define how much of it you can be made to pay for.

Can I refinance out of an adjustable loan before it resets?

Yes, and many borrowers plan on it, but the plan depends on rates and on your equity at that future date rather than on today. If rates are higher or the home has lost value, refinancing may not be available or may not save anything. Treat a planned refinance as a hope and the lifetime cap payment as the commitment. Closing costs also have to be recovered, which is a break-even calculation in months, not an assumption.

Does the calculator handle an adjustable rate correctly?

It handles the initial period correctly and holds the rate for the whole term, so it does not model the reset. For an adjustable loan, run the numbers at the starter rate to see the near-term payment, then run the remaining balance at the fully indexed rate and at the lifetime cap. The gap between those two runs is the range you are actually signing up for, and it is more informative than any single blended estimate.

Related calculators

Estimates only, not financial advice. Thresholds, cancellation rights and rate caps depend on your loan documents and your servicer. See Disclaimer.

By Panyian, editor and maintainer · Updated · How this site is maintained